Bethany Raney

Real Estate

Say “Yes”
to the Address!

I’m a real estate agent with Shook in Lafayette, IN and the nearby area, providing home-buyers and sellers with professional, responsive and attentive real estate services.

Buyers:

Want an agent who’ll really listen to what you want in a home?

Buyer Information

Sellers:

Need an agent who knows how to effectively market your home so it sells?

Seller Information

Give me a call! I’m eager to help and would love to talk to you.

My Listings

in the Lafayette / West Lafayette area

Let's Sell Your House!

Featured

Save

1125 Blubaugh Ave Thorntown IN 46071 image 1

1125 Blubaugh Ave Thorntown IN 46071 image 2

1125 Blubaugh Ave Thorntown IN 46071 image 3

1125 Blubaugh Ave Thorntown IN 46071 image 4

1125 Blubaugh Ave Thorntown IN 46071 image 5

1125 W Blubaugh Ave, Thorntown, IN 46071, USA

$715,000

1125 W Blubaugh Ave, Thorntown, IN 46071, USA

Welcome to 1125 W Blubaugh Ave! Discover peaceful country living...

4 beds

2 baths

2447 sq ft

1125 W Blubaugh Ave, Thorntown, IN 46071, USA

Save

$715,000

Featured

Save

3626 E 800 S, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

$1,000,000

3626 E 800 S, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Welcome to 3626 E 800 S in Lafayette! Escape to...

2 beds

1 bath

810 sq ft

3626 E 800 S, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Save

$1,000,000

Featured

Save

3280 Elm Swamp Rd Lebanon IN 46052 image 1

3280 Elm Swamp Rd Lebanon IN 46052 image 2

3280 Elm Swamp Rd Lebanon IN 46052 image 3

3280 Elm Swamp Rd Lebanon IN 46052 image 5

3280 Elm Swamp Rd, Lebanon, IN 46052, USA

$340,000

3280 Elm Swamp Rd, Lebanon, IN 46052, USA

Nestled in a peaceful rural setting, this beautifully updated 3...

3 beds

2 baths

1537 sq ft

3280 Elm Swamp Rd, Lebanon, IN 46052, USA

Save

$340,000

Featured

Save

4652 Jeremiah St West Lafayette IN 47906 image 1

4652 Jeremiah St West Lafayette IN 47906 image 2

4652 Jeremiah St West Lafayette IN 47906 image 3

4652 Jeremiah St West Lafayette IN 47906 image 4

4652 Jeremiah St West Lafayette IN 47906 image 5

4652 Jeremiah St, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

$285,000

4652 Jeremiah St, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bath home...

3 beds

2 baths

1436 sq ft

4652 Jeremiah St, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Save

$285,000

Featured

Save

1910 Abnaki Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 1

1910 Abnaki Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 2

1910 Abnaki Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 3

1910 Abnaki Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 4

1910 Abnaki Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 5

1910 Abnaki Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

$275,000

1910 Abnaki Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Welcome to 1910 Abnaki Dr in West Lafayette! Located just...

3 beds

2 baths

1200 sq ft

1910 Abnaki Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Save

$275,000

Featured

Save

3307 Secretariat Circle West Lafayette IN 47906 image 1

3307 Secretariat Circle West Lafayette IN 47906 image 2

3307 Secretariat Circle West Lafayette IN 47906 image 3

3307 Secretariat Circle West Lafayette IN 47906 image 4

3307 Secretariat Circle West Lafayette IN 47906 image 5

3307 Secretariat Cir, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

$470,000

3307 Secretariat Cir, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Step into this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial home in...

4 beds

2 baths

2385 sq ft

3307 Secretariat Cir, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Save

$470,000

Featured

Save

2092 Ironbridge Ct Lafayette IN 47905 image 1

2092 Ironbridge Ct Lafayette IN 47905 image 2

2092 Ironbridge Ct Lafayette IN 47905 image 3

2092 Ironbridge Ct Lafayette IN 47905 image 4

2092 Ironbridge Ct Lafayette IN 47905 image 5

2092 Ironbridge Ct, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

$615,000

2092 Ironbridge Ct, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

This is the one you have been waiting for! Welcome...

5 beds

4 baths

5671 sq ft

2092 Ironbridge Ct, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

Save

$615,000

Featured

Save

297 Indigo St Lafayette IN 47909 image 1

297 Indigo St Lafayette IN 47909 image 2

297 Indigo St Lafayette IN 47909 image 3

297 Indigo St Lafayette IN 47909 image 4

297 Indigo St Lafayette IN 47909 image 5

297 Indigo St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

$394,900

297 Indigo St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Welcome to 297 Indigo St, in Butler Meadows! This stunning...

4 beds

2 baths

3240 sq ft

297 Indigo St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Save

$394,900

Featured

Save

1004 Shenandoah Dr Lafayette IN 47905 image 1

1004 Shenandoah Dr Lafayette IN 47905 image 2

1004 Shenandoah Dr Lafayette IN 47905 image 3

1004 Shenandoah Dr Lafayette IN 47905 image 4

1004 Shenandoah Dr Lafayette IN 47905 image 5

1004 Shenandoah Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

$195,000

1004 Shenandoah Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

🚌 LSC Schools 3 🛌 1 🛁 900 st ft...

3 beds

1 bath

900 sq ft

1004 Shenandoah Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

Save

$195,000

Featured

Save

3789 Ensley St Lafayette IN 47909 image 1

3789 Ensley St Lafayette IN 47909 image 2

3789 Ensley St Lafayette IN 47909 image 3

3789 Ensley St Lafayette IN 47909 image 4

3789 Ensley St Lafayette IN 47909 image 5

3789 Ensley St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

$389,997

3789 Ensley St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-story home, featuring an open-concept...

5 beds

3 baths

3256 sq ft

3789 Ensley St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Save

$389,997

Featured

Save

916 Rosemont St Lafayette IN 47909 image 1

916 Rosemont St Lafayette IN 47909 image 2

916 Rosemont St Lafayette IN 47909 image 3

916 Rosemont St Lafayette IN 47909 image 4

916 Rosemont St Lafayette IN 47909 image 5

916 Rosemont St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

$178,000

916 Rosemont St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Welcome to this cozy 2 bedroom, 1 bath home, perfect...

2 beds

1 bath

824 sq ft

916 Rosemont St, Lafayette, IN 47909, USA

Save

$178,000

Featured

Save

13026 S 475 W, Romney, IN 47981, USA

$305,000

13026 S 475 W, Romney, IN 47981, USA

Welcome to 475 W! This home is nestled on a...

2 beds

1 bath

1456 sq ft

13026 S 475 W, Romney, IN 47981, USA

Save

$305,000

Save

641 Fox Trail West Lafayette IN 47906 image 1

641 Fox Trail West Lafayette IN 47906 image 2

641 Fox Trail West Lafayette IN 47906 image 3

641 Fox Trail West Lafayette IN 47906 image 4

641 Fox Trail West Lafayette IN 47906 image 5

641 Fox Trail, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

$665,000

641 Fox Trail, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Your very own private paradise awaits! Park like setting, with...

3 beds

2 baths

2628 sq ft

641 Fox Trail, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Save

$665,000

Save

303 W Vine St, Oxford, IN 47971, USA

Welcome to 303 W Vine St! This cute 2 story...

303 W Vine St, Oxford, IN 47971, USA

Save

Featured

Save

2809 Horizon Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 1

2809 Horizon Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 2

2809 Horizon Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 3

2809 Horizon Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 4

2809 Horizon Dr West Lafayette IN 47906 image 5

2809 Horizon Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

$399,900

2809 Horizon Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Welcome to 2809 Horizon Dr in West Lafayette. This 4...

2809 Horizon Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47906, USA

Save

$399,900

Featured

Save

3240 Sherwood Dr S Lafayette IN 47905 image 1

3240 Sherwood Dr S Lafayette IN 47905 image 2

3240 Sherwood Dr S Lafayette IN 47905 image 3

3240 Sherwood Dr S Lafayette IN 47905 image 4

3240 Sherwood Dr S Lafayette IN 47905 image 5

$255,000

Welcome to 3240 Sherwood Dr in Lafayette! This wonderful 3...

3 beds

2 baths

1624 sq ft

Save

$255,000

Save

1107 Mitchell Ave Monticello IN 47960 image 1

1107 Mitchell Ave Monticello IN 47960 image 2

1107 Mitchell Ave Monticello IN 47960 image 3

1107 Mitchell Ave Monticello IN 47960 image 4

1107 Mitchell Ave Monticello IN 47960 image 5

1107 Mitchell Ave, Monticello, IN 47960, USA

$219,500

1107 Mitchell Ave, Monticello, IN 47960, USA

Welcome to 1107 Mitchell Ave! This 3 bedroom 1 bath...

32294 beds

2193 baths

1251 sq ft

1107 Mitchell Ave, Monticello, IN 47960, USA

Save

$219,500

Save

903 S. Willow Street Flora IN 46929 image 1

903 S. Willow Street Flora IN 46929 image 2

903 S. Willow Street Flora IN 46929 image 3

903 S. Willow Street Flora IN 46929 image 4

903 S. Willow Street Flora IN 46929 image 5

903 S Willow St, Flora, IN 46929, USA

$155,000

903 S Willow St, Flora, IN 46929, USA

2 1 974 sq ft with unfinished basement 1.25 acres...

2 beds

1 bath

974 sq ft

903 S Willow St, Flora, IN 46929, USA

Save

$155,000

Save

1306 Sourgum Lane Lafayette IN 47905 image 1

1306 Sourgum Lane Lafayette IN 47905 image 2

1306 Sourgum Lane Lafayette IN 47905 image 3

1306 Sourgum Lane Lafayette IN 47905 image 4

1306 Sourgum Lane Lafayette IN 47905 image 5

1306 Sourgum Ln, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

$280,000

1306 Sourgum Ln, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

Welcome to 1306 Sourgum Ln! This 2 story home with...

3 beds

2 baths

1874 sq ft

1306 Sourgum Ln, Lafayette, IN 47905, USA

Save

$280,000

Save

527 W 950 S, Brookston, IN 47923, USA

$190,000

527 W 950 S, Brookston, IN 47923, USA

Looking for a little piece and quiet? Welcome to 527...

4 beds

1 bath

2672 sq ft

527 W 950 S, Brookston, IN 47923, USA

Save

$190,000

5 out of 5 stars

Stephen Johnson

10/18/2025

I used Bethany's services to seek my home is Lafayette. I had an interesting timeline that changed a few times. I have to say she was awesome and flexible with me the entire time! Also, her understanding of the local market was above the other 3 realtors I spoke with (who were all good). She not only knew the market, but also the specific neighborhoods. She absolutely helped me get top dollar and what my home was worth. She was also easy to work with and not pushy which worked great with my personality 😀
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Ashley McManners

10/08/2025

We had such a great experience working with Bethany! She was professional, patient, and truly went above and beyond to make the process smooth from start to finish. Communication was excellent — every question we had was answered quickly, and she made sure we always felt informed and supported. We couldn’t be happier with our new home and would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell!
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

marlye cochran

10/03/2025

Bethany went above and beyond for us! She is so knowledgeable, experienced, and truly personal in her approach. She’s not just trying to sell you a house—she genuinely wants to help you find the perfect home. We trusted her opinion while touring homes, and she pointed out things we never would have noticed on our own. That insight gave us so much clarity in what we were looking for.

As first-time homebuyers, we couldn’t have asked for a better guide. She made the process not only easy but actually fun! We’ll absolutely be coming back to her for any future sales or purchases, and we would recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor who will truly represent them.
read moreread less
5 out of 5 stars

david kyle

10/07/2024

Bethany was awesome with helping us pick our first house! She’s very kind and helpful, she made it easy and simple an doesn’t rush you into anything. I highly recommend her!!! Thanks Bethany again for your hardwork
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Kevin Minchow

8/01/2024

Bethany was great every step of the way when it came to finding and buying our home in Lafayette, IN. We had limited time to look for houses because we were living outside the country before we purchased our home in Lafayette. Bethany went above and beyond to communicate with us even with a 6 hour time difference and limited access to normal contact methods. She is an expert in the area and knows every part of town and what to expect for prices and availability in the different neighbors. She really listened to what we wanted and took extra time to make sure we saw every house we wanted. I was especially impressed with her commitment to helping us out after we purchased our home and before we could get moved in. She was there with us every step of the way and made moving half way across the globe a much easier experience than I could have imagined.
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Bob Elness

7/08/2024

I highly recommend Bethany Raney for any and all all of your Real Estate needs. In 2020 she helped my wife and I purchase our dream retirement home, and then in 2024 she helped us sell my son's house in the midst of tragic circumstances. In both cases she guided and helped us all along the way, was available whenever we needed her, and went above and beyond whatever was necessary to make sure we got the very best deal possible. So whether you're buying or selling, I would strongly suggest that you call Bethany!
read moreread less
5 out of 5 stars

Grace Campbell

12/02/2023

Bethany was a fantastic person to work with when we closed on our home this August 2023! She went above and beyond to tour homes with us- multiple times we went on tours of multiple homes for many hours at a time because of our busy schedule (once we toured homes for 8 hours straight on a weekend), and she was not only a great sport about it but planned it all for us quickly and happily! Bethany is a joy and very fun to talk with, and very knowledgeable and dedicated to her profession. She also helped my parents buy and sell their home in 2020 and they absolutely love her, as well. She keeps in touch with her clients and sent us a lovely holiday card this year (with a target gift card, my favorite store)! Highly recommend Bethany as a realtor to anyone looking to buy or sell!
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Janet Reed

6/16/2023

If you are looking to sell you're home. I recommend Bethany Rainey. She was with my husband and I from the start to the finish. She gave us encouragement, as to what we needed to do to make this sale happen. I believe she went above and beyond to get this done. The first day we got an offer and then another the next day , when we were thinking it might take all summer.
Bethany you are amazing and Garry and I appreciate all you have done. Thank you.
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Jane Martin

12/29/2022

Bethany was very professional and knowledgeable; we relied on her expertise and were quite pleased. I would use her again if I were looking to buy or sell the Lafyette area.
read moreread less
5 out of 5 stars

Luke Neihouser

10/20/2022

My wife and I had a fantastic experience with Bethany. She showed us numerous houses and was very honest with us! Bethany is very knowledgeable and is great for all situations!
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Jerry Yotter

7/30/2022

Bethany is very knowledgeable and patient. We were purchasing a home in an area we were not familiar with and she was able to provide great feedback. She is also very very responsive when we reach out with any questions. We also had to look at all of the homes virtually and she was very quick to reach out to the agent and schedule a showing for us. I strongly encourage reaching out to her for your real estate needs.
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Linda Williams

7/07/2022

Bethany Raney is an awesome realtor!! She helped me sell my house for over asking price. She is very informative and an awesome person to work with. She always kept me updated and informed on everything. Thank you Bethany!! I wish you and your family all the best!!
read moreread less
5 out of 5 stars

Kristen Sheller

1/20/2022

Bethany helped us buy a house remotely, and we were on a very strict time line. She was very responsive and took a lot of time to help us get our house. She made the process very smooth and we could not be happier. She takes pride in what she does and truley cares about people. I highly recommend her!
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

Dane Harper

1/19/2022

Bethany did a fantastic job of helping us buy a home and then sell our home.
read moreread less

5 out of 5 stars

McKenzie Temme

9/27/2021

Bethany Raney was an awesome realtor. She worked with our tight work relocation timeline and helped us to find our dream home even with how crazy the housing market got. We had a small issue come up with our house right before closing, but Bethany helped us to get it satisfactorily resolved. We also really appreciated Bethany’s knowledge of the area and ability to point out and recommend amenities and services for the whole family. I would highly recommend Bethany Raney as a realtor.
read moreread less